Joel Greenblatt Magic Formula Calculator
Test whether a stock combines above-average business quality with a bargain valuation using Joel Greenblatt's two core ratios—Return on Capital (ROC) and Earnings Yield (EY)—complete with benchmark checks and plain-English interpretation.
Magic Formula Calculator: Benchmark Check
Enter a stock's Return on Capital and Earnings Yield to test Greenblatt's >20% ROC and >10% EY rules of thumb.
EBIT ÷ (Net Working Capital + Net Fixed Assets). Greenblatt rule of thumb: > 20%.
EBIT ÷ Enterprise Value. Greenblatt rule of thumb: > 10% (under 10x EV/EBIT).
28.50%
Generates $28.50 in annual EBIT per $100 of tangible operating capital.
12.40%
Implied valuation multiple: 8.1x EV/EBIT (10% EY = 10.0x EV/EBIT).
Passes Both Greenblatt Benchmarks (Quality + Bargain Price)
2 of 2 Benchmarks MetAt a 28.5% Return on Capital and a 12.4% Earnings Yield (roughly 8.1x EV/EBIT), this stock clears both of Joel Greenblatt’s conventional rules of thumb (ROC > 20% and EY > 10%). The business generates $28.50 in pre-tax operating profit for every $100 of tangible capital employed, while the market prices the entire enterprise at a double-digit pre-tax yield.
What to check next: Before buying, verify that trailing EBIT is not an unsustainable cyclical spike (common in energy, shipping, or commodities) and confirm the company is not facing structural decline.
Note: In Joel Greenblatt's institutional screen, stocks are ranked across the entire market on ROC and EY rather than filtered by rigid cutoffs—so a 19% ROC / 9.5% EY stock can still rank highly when overall market valuations are elevated.
What Is the Magic Formula?
Introduced by Gotham Capital founder and Columbia Business School adjunct professor Joel Greenblatt in The Little Book That Beats the Market (2005), the Magic Formula turns buying good businesses at bargain prices into two quantitative metrics:
- Return on Capital (ROC) measures business quality: pre-tax operating profit generated per dollar of tangible working capital and physical equipment.
- Earnings Yield (EY) measures valuation: pre-tax operating profit per dollar of total Enterprise Value, including debt and net of excess cash.
Greenblatt built the Magic Formula around a combined ranking system rather than fixed thresholds. Across roughly 3,500 U.S. non-financial, non-utility stocks, every company is ranked from 1 to 3,500 on ROC and separately from 1 to 3,500 on Earnings Yield, then sorted by the sum of both ranks. A stock ranked 60th in ROC and 95th in Earnings Yield (Combined Rank 155) beats a cheap value trap ranked 5th in Earnings Yield yet 2,800th in ROC.
Ranking adapts automatically to market cycles: bear markets produce hundreds of high-yield stocks, while bull markets leave rigid screens nearly empty. When checking a single stock without a full 3,500-company database, Greenblatt's conventional benchmarks—ROC > 20% and Earnings Yield > 10%—provide fast, reliable rules of thumb.
The Two Formulas Behind It
Rather than relying on standard P/E or Return on Assets, Greenblatt pulls specific operating and balance-sheet items from a company's Form 10-K or Form 10-Q filings.
Return on Capital: ROC = EBIT ÷ (Net Working Capital + Net Fixed Assets)
ROC = EBIT ÷ (Net Working Capital + Net Fixed Assets)
EBIT (Income Statement): Trailing twelve-month Operating Income from the Consolidated Statements of Operations—profit from core operations before interest expense and income taxes.
Net Working Capital (Balance Sheet): Operating current assets minus non-interest-bearing current liabilities on the Consolidated Balance Sheets. Subtract excess cash and short-term marketable securities from Total Current Assets (leaving receivables, inventory, and prepaid expenses), then subtract short-term debt and current debt maturities from Total Current Liabilities (leaving payables, accrued expenses, and deferred revenue). Floor negative results at zero.
Net Fixed Assets (Balance Sheet): Property, Plant, and Equipment, net (gross buildings, machinery, and equipment less accumulated depreciation). Goodwill and acquired intangibles are excluded because opening a new store or factory does not require re-paying past acquisition premiums.
Earnings Yield: EY = EBIT ÷ Enterprise Value
Earnings Yield = EBIT ÷ (Market Cap + Total Debt + Preferred Stock − Excess Cash)
EBIT (Income Statement): The same trailing twelve-month Operating Income from the Consolidated Statements of Operations.
Enterprise Value (Market Quote + Balance Sheet): Multiply share price by shares outstanding (from the 10-K cover or Income Statement) for Market Capitalization. From the Balance Sheet, add total interest-bearing debt (short-term debt, current debt maturities, and long-term debt) plus preferred stock and noncontrolling interest, then subtract cash, cash equivalents, and short-term marketable securities. Using Enterprise Value instead of Market Cap prevents debt-laden firms from looking artificially cheap on a P/E basis.
A Real Example: Running Apple (AAPL) Through the Magic Formula
To see how every line item fits together—including why Greenblatt's working-capital adjustment matters in practice—let's walk through Apple Inc. (AAPL) using official figures from Apple's FY2026 Form 10-K (for the fiscal year ended September 26, 2026, filed with the SEC on November 3, 2026) and Apple's closing share price of $348.51 on November 10, 2026.
Data as of Nov 10, 2026 (AAPL closing share price) and fiscal year ended Sep 26, 2026 (Apple Inc. FY2026 Form 10-K; dollar amounts in millions).
| Component / Line Item | FY2026 Amount | Where It Comes From |
|---|---|---|
| EBIT (Operating income) | $158,063M | FY2026 10-K, Statements of Operations |
| Total current assets | $173,857M | Cash $36,305M + current marketable securities $20,417M + A/R $43,817M + vendor receivables $39,896M + inventory $14,541M + other $18,881M |
| Operating current assets (excl. cash & short-term securities) | $117,135M | $173,857M − ($36,305M + $20,417M) |
| Total current liabilities | $169,915M | Accounts payable $82,252M + other current $66,124M + deferred revenue $9,636M + commercial paper $1,997M + current term debt $9,906M |
| Non-interest-bearing current liabilities | $158,012M | $169,915M − ($1,997M + $9,906M short-term debt) |
| Adjusted Net Working Capital (floored at $0) | $0M | Raw operating NWC is $117,135M − $158,012M = −$40,877M → set to $0 per Greenblatt |
| Net Fixed Assets (Property, plant & equipment, net) | $52,084M | FY2026 10-K, Consolidated Balance Sheets |
| Market Capitalization (Nov 10, 2026) | $5,064,611M | 14,532,182,000 shares (10-K cover, Oct 23, 2026) × $348.51 close |
| Total interest-bearing debt | $80,111M | Commercial paper $1,997M + current term debt $9,906M + non-current term debt $68,208M |
| Enterprise Value (EV) | $5,088,000M | $5,064,611M market cap + $80,111M debt − $56,722M cash & current marketable securities |
Step 1 — Calculate Return on Capital (ROC): Because Apple collects cash from customers quickly while paying component suppliers later, its non-interest-bearing current liabilities ($158,012 million) exceed its operating current assets ($117,135 million) by $40,877 million. Applying Greenblatt's zero-floor rule sets Net Working Capital to $0 million, leaving Tangible Capital Employed equal to Net Fixed Assets of $52,084 million:
ROC = $158,063M ÷ ($0M + $52,084M) = 3.0348 = 303.48%
(Even if you skipped Greenblatt's adjustment and plugged in unadjusted current assets minus current liabilities—$173,857M − $169,915M = $3,942M—Tangible Capital would be $56,026 million and ROC would still be a massive 282.12%.)
Step 2 — Calculate Earnings Yield (EY): Dividing Apple's $158,063 million in operating income by its $5,088,000 million Enterprise Value gives:
Earnings Yield = $158,063M ÷ $5,088,000M = 0.03107 = 3.11% (32.2x EV/EBIT)
(Note: Apple also holds $80,213 million in non-current marketable securities on its balance sheet. If you deduct all $136,935 million of cash plus current and non-current marketable securities, Enterprise Value drops slightly to $5,007,787 million and Earnings Yield edges up to 3.16%—an identical conclusion.)
What Apple's result tells us: Click the "Apple FY2026" preset in the calculator at the top of this page and you immediately see why Greenblatt tracks two separate rankings. Apple's 303.48% ROC crushes the 20% quality benchmark more than fifteen times over—confirming one of the most capital-efficient business models in corporate history. Yet its 3.11% Earnings Yield sits far below the 10% bargain benchmark because investors are already paying more than 32 times operating profit for that excellence.
How to Read Your Result
Benchmark ranges: Median Return on Tangible Capital across U.S. operating companies sits near 12% to 15%. An ROC above 20% signals a durable competitive moat—pricing power, brand strength, or proprietary technology—while 50%+ points to an asset-light model. For Earnings Yield, compare pre-tax operating return against the 10-year U.S. Treasury yield (roughly 4% to 4.5%): an Earnings Yield above 10% (under 10x EV/EBIT) offers more than double the risk-free pre-tax yield. Readings of 6% to 10% (10x–16.7x EV/EBIT) reflect fair value for steady compounders, whereas yields below 5% price in substantial future growth.
Industry differences: Software, payment networks, and franchised brands carry minimal inventory and PP&E, routinely posting 40% to 100%+ ROC. Capital-intensive railroads, chip foundries, and heavy manufacturers carry large fixed-asset bases, making an 18% to 22% ROC impressive in those sectors. Always watch for cyclical traps—oil producers, steelmakers, and shippers often flash 30%+ ROC and 15%+ Earnings Yield at cycle peaks right before earnings drop.
Why banks and insurance companies distort the formula: Greenblatt excludes financial firms because their balance sheets do not run on Net Working Capital + Net Fixed Assets. For a bank, loans are inventory, customer deposits are funding liabilities, and net interest spread is gross margin—so pre-interest EBIT is meaningless and physical PP&E (branches and servers) is tiny. Insurers similarly invest policyholder float held against future claim reserves rather than working capital and factories. Dividing financial profits by working capital plus office buildings produces distorted ROC spikes while debt-based Enterprise Value breaks down; use ROE and Price-to-Tangible-Book for financials instead.
Magic Formula vs Other Valuation Methods
The Magic Formula is a relative quality-and-price screen rather than an intrinsic price-target generator. Pairing it with complementary valuation models sharpens your buy discipline:
| Method | Core Metrics | Best Used For | Main Blind Spot |
|---|---|---|---|
| Magic Formula (Greenblatt) | ROC & Earnings Yield (EBIT/EV) | Screening capital-efficient non-financial stocks trading at low EV/EBIT multiples | Uses trailing single-year EBIT; ignores multi-year growth rate differences and financials |
| Graham Number | EPS & Book Value Per Share | Setting a strict defensive ceiling price on asset-backed value stocks | Penalizes asset-light compounders with low book value (like Apple or software firms) |
| PEG & PEGY Ratios | P/E, EPS Growth & Dividend Yield | Growth-at-a-reasonable-price (GARP) stocks and dividend-paying compounders | Relies on projected growth estimates and uses equity P/E rather than debt-adjusted EV |
| Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) | Projected Free Cash Flow & WACC | Calculating exact intrinsic dollar value per share once a stock passes an initial screen | Sensitive to 5–10 year growth, discount rate, and terminal value assumptions |
If you prefer old-school balance-sheet protection on mature industrial names, check the Benjamin Graham formula, though remember that Graham's book-value cap will reject asset-light winners that score 100%+ ROC under Greenblatt. When a company clears the 20% ROC hurdle but fails the 10% Earnings Yield check because it is growing earnings at 18% a year, run it through our Peter Lynch fair value calculator for non-dividend growers, or switch to the PEGY ratio calculator when steady dividends supply a big slice of your expected return. Finally, because the Magic Formula screens on a single trailing year of EBIT without outputting a target share price, always verify your shortlisted candidates with our DCF-based fair value calculator to estimate intrinsic value per share and your exact margin of safety.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does Joel Greenblatt use EBIT instead of Net Income?
Net income is distorted by differing debt loads (interest expense) and one-off tax credits. Pre-tax operating profit (EBIT) lets you compare the operating earning power of a debt-free firm and a leveraged firm on equal footing alongside Enterprise Value.
Is Return on Capital (ROC) the same as ROE or ROIC?
No. Return on Equity (ROE) can be inflated with debt or buybacks, and standard ROIC usually keeps acquisition goodwill in the denominator. Greenblatt's ROC strips out goodwill, intangibles, excess cash, and short-term debt to measure returns strictly on tangible operating capital.
What should I do when Net Working Capital is negative?
When accounts payable and deferred revenue exceed operating current assets, Net Working Capital turns negative. Following Greenblatt's appendix rules, floor negative Net Working Capital at zero so supplier float does not shrink Tangible Capital Employed below Net Fixed Assets.
How many stocks does Greenblatt recommend holding, and for how long?
Greenblatt designed the strategy for a basket of 20 to 30 top-ranked stocks accumulated over several months and rebalanced annually. Holding a single cheap stock carries high company-specific risk unless backed by deeper fundamental research.
Why are utilities and REITs excluded alongside banks and insurers?
Regulated utilities operate under state-capped returns with heavy grid debt, while REITs carry mortgage leverage on property portfolios and pass through taxable income. Both structures skew Enterprise Value and tangible asset turnover against ordinary operating companies.
Does a high ROC and high Earnings Yield guarantee a bargain?
Not automatically. Commodity producers, homebuilders, shippers, and memory-chip makers often show 35% ROC and 15% Earnings Yield right at a cyclical peak—just before operating profit drops by half. Check three-to-five-year average EBIT margins first.